Please login to experience the full glory of the Dragoon forums!

How complex is too complex for MMOs?

Go down

How complex is too complex for MMOs?

Post by TheHidden01 on Fri Jun 21, 2013 2:40 pm

I'm a huge fan of isometric clickers like Diablo, Torchlight, and Titan Quest, so I admit to being secretly pleased when pseudo-MMOs like Path of Exile were approved for coverage on Massively. In fact, I jumped into Path of Exile this past weekend to give it another spin. And as soon as my new character got her first skill point, I gleefully clicked over to the skill panel, only to be confronted with the game's notorious and glorious SKILL TREE TO END ALL SKILL TREES. It's not even a skill tree. It's a skill maze. A skill constellation. A skill galaxy. The screenshot above isn't even half of what's available. It's overwhelming at level 2 to say the least.

I like complexity in character development, but I had forgotten how over-the-top Path of Exile really was, and I had to wonder whether this sort of complexity-dump scares off newcomers to the genre, or indeed, whether it's intended to scare them off, convince them the game is harder-core than they are, or possibly just entrap them with poor early game decisions. Doesn't the skill avalanche just drive gamers to tab out and look up guides, and is that really the best idea for retaining brand-new players? How complex is too complex for MMOs and pseudo-MMOs?


The Dragoon King;

"Let your character be your weapon, your fellow guild members be your armour, your blood thirst be your helmet, and use your boots to make a stand. After every battle allow your shield to be your faith in one another, and return from battle either carrying it or resting upon it."

Dorek: hopefully it has ingame voip
Dorek: then you could shout at em
Dorek: besides you sound like a fucking psycho anyway so you would make em piss emselves

Currently Watching:- Supernatural, and Avatar
Dragoon King
Dragoon King

Number of posts : 19972
Age : 29
Location : Somerset, UK
Position in Command : King
Reputation : 46
Points : 46130
Registration date : 2007-03-11

Back to top Go down

Re: How complex is too complex for MMOs?

Post by Aqura on Fri Jun 21, 2013 3:59 pm

Complexity is needed in combat, not in pseudo different traits... For me the amount of choice in MxO was about perfect (almost all skills were viable unlike GW2 ofc otherwise it'd be on par).

That screenshot doesn't say complexity to me, it screams chaos and a mess to balance...
Chief Warrant Officer 4
Chief Warrant Officer 4

Number of posts : 729
Age : 28
Location : Sweden/Bulgaria
Other Names : Swim
Reputation : 4
Points : 5344
Registration date : 2007-05-12

Back to top Go down

Back to top

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum